• Skip to content
  • Skip to footer
  • Accessibility options
University of Brighton
  • About us
  • Business and
    employers
  • Alumni and
    supporters
  • For
    students
  • For
    staff
  • Accessibility
    options
Open menu
Home
Home
  • Close
  • Study here
    • Courses and subjects
    • Find a course
    • A-Z course list
    • Explore our subjects
    • Academic departments
    • Visiting the university
    • Explore: get to know us
    • Upcoming events
    • Virtual tours
    • Chat to our students and staff
    • Open days
    • Applicant days
    • Order a prospectus
    • Ask a question
    • Studying here
    • Accommodation and locations
    • Applying
    • Undergraduate
    • Postgraduate
    • Transferring from another university
    • The Student Contract
    • Clearing
    • International students
    • Fees and finance
    • Advice and help
    • Advice for students
    • Advice for parents and carers
    • Advice for schools and teachers
    • Managing your application
    • Undergraduate
    • Postgraduate
    • Apprenticeships
  • Research
    • Research and knowledge exchange
    • Research and knowledge exchange organisation
    • The Global Challenges
    • Centres of Research Excellence (COREs)
    • Research Excellence Groups (REGs)
    • Our research database
    • Information for business
    • Community University Partnership Programme (CUPP)
    • Postgraduate research degrees
    • PhD research disciplines and programmes
    • PhD funding opportunities and studentships
    • How to apply for your PhD
    • Research environment
    • Investing in research careers
    • Strategic plan
    • Research concordat
    • News, events, publications and films
    • Featured research and knowledge exchange projects
    • Research and knowledge exchange news
    • Inaugural lectures
    • Research and knowledge exchange publications and films
    • Academic staff search
  • About us
  • Business and employers
  • Alumni, supporters and giving
  • Current students
  • Staff
  • Accessibility
Search our site
Research-project-banner
Research and knowledge exchange
  • Postgraduate research degrees
  • Research features
  • Research organisation
  • Research environment
  • Groups
    • Groups
    • Applied geosciences
    • Built environment
    • Biomaterials and Drug Delivery
    • Brighton and Sussex Medicines Optimisation
    • Chemistry
    • Stress, ageing and disease
    • Ecosystems and environmental management
    • Education
    • Environment and public health
    • Healthcare Practice and Rehabilitation
    • Interdisciplinary Management and Higher Education
    • Management and Employment
    • Mathematics, Statistics and Operations
    • Musculoskeletal
    • Nuclear physics
    • Past human and environment dynamics
    • Paediatrics
    • Product design
    • Sensory neuroscience
    • Social Science Policy
    • Society space and environment
    • Sport and Exercise Science and Medicine
    • Sport, Tourism and Leisure
    • Sustainability and Resilience Engineering
    • Transforming sexuality and gender
    • Values and sustainability
  • Management and Employment
    • Management and Employment
    • Research impact
    • Research areas
    • Research projects
    • Collaborations
    • Events
    • About us
  • Research projects
    • Research projects
    • Alcohol use and young people's offending
    • Customer service behaviour
    • Effects of unemployment on different ethnic groups
    • Employee performance and wellbeing
    • Employment patterns for Polish migrants in south-east England
    • Engagement
    • Gamification in human resources
    • Grandparents and childcare
    • Human rights and four schools of thought
    • Human rights and migrants
    • ITHACA
    • Leadership of organisational change
    • Legal regulation of trade unions
    • Litigants in person
    • Management consultancy and corporate identity
    • Management consultancy and the public sector
    • Managing global human resources in UK multi-national corporations
    • Meaningfulness initiatives
    • MinAs: unaccompanied minors' rights
    • Multinational corporations and human rights
    • NEGOTIATE
    • New vocationalism
    • Occupational regulation and its impact
    • Organisational change failure
    • Restorative justice and young people's offending
    • STYLE Strategic Transitions for Youth Labour in Europe
    • The transformation of retirement? The UK and the US compared
    • Trade union identities and the role of niche unionism
    • Whistleblowing legislation
    • Work care synergies
    • Youth transitions into work: a UK Spanish comparison
  • Human rights and four schools of thought

Human rights and four schools of thought

Professor Marie-Bénédicte Dembour’s groundbreaking work challenges the human rights orthodoxy by proposing that there are four schools of thought. First published in her monograph, Who Believes in Human Rights? Reflections on the European Convention (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2006), her model asserts that:

  • ‘natural scholars’ conceive of human rights as given
  • ‘deliberative scholars’ as agreed upon
  • ‘protest scholars’ as fought for
  • ‘discourse scholars’ as talked about.

The model allows differing positions on the foundation, universality, possible realisation and legal embodiment of human rights to be explored. Through mapping the different schools, she gives greater clarity to debate within the human rights field.

Project timeframe

This research project commenced in 2006 and is ongoing.

Project objectives

The objectives of the research were to:

  • improve understanding about approaches to human rights
  • develop a model to enable the mapping of the entire human rights conceptual field
  • explore the position of each school of thought in relation to human rights law and on the foundation, realisation, universality and overall faith in human rights.
Each school of thought presents persuasive arguments – all have something of interest to offer. Not surprisingly then, many scholars waver in their orientations.

Professor Marie-Bénédicte Dembour

Project findings and impact

The model quickly reached top most downloaded article status when it was published in the leading journal, Human Rights Quarterly, and has provided structure for subsequent research by Dembour into the problematic access to human rights experienced by irregular migrants.

The model was the subject of the prestigious Torkel Opashl Memorial Lecture given at the University of Oslo in 2009 and keynote addresses in 2011 at both the symposium organised by the Dutch branch of Amnesty International to celebrate its fiftieth anniversary and the Nordic Educational Research Association (NERA) conference on rights and education in Finland.

In addition, Professor Dembour lectured on the model at the Institut Universitaire Kurt Bösch in Switzerland and was invited by Clingendeal, the Netherlands Institute of International Relations, to present her findings in courses developed for diplomats from the Arab region in 2013.

By introducing new, theoretical mapping of human rights scholarship, Dembour has managed to reframe approaches and debate within the field. Dembour expanded on her research into human rights. Read the project page detailing work on Human rights and migrants and the accompanying blog for more information.


Research team

Professor Marie-Bénédicte Dembour

Output

Dembour, M-B (2006) Who Believes in Human Rights? Reflections on the European Convention, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Dembour, M-B & Kelly, T (2011) Are Human Rights for Migrants? Critical Perspectives on the Status of Illegal Migrants in Europe and the United States, Routledge, London.

Partners

Professor Tobias Kelly, University of Edinburgh

Back to top
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn icon

Contact us

University of Brighton
Mithras House
Lewes Road
Brighton
BN2 4AT

Main switchboard 01273 600900

Course enquiries

Sign up for updates

University contacts

Report a problem with this page

Quick links Quick links

  • Courses
  • Open days
  • Order a prospectus
  • Academic departments
  • Academic staff
  • Professional services departments
  • Jobs
  • Privacy and cookie policy
  • Accessibility statement
  • Libraries
  • Term dates
  • Maps
  • Graduation
  • Site information
  • Online shop
  • COVID-19

Information for Information for

  • Current students
  • International students
  • Media/press
  • Careers advisers/teachers
  • Parents/carers
  • Business/employers
  • Alumni/supporters
  • Suppliers
  • Local residents